
The documents these women presented were deemed invalid.
What’s it called when, with one sweep of a pen or publication of a report, millions of people `lose’ their citizenship. Today, India dropped over four million people living in the resource-rich state of Assam, in northeast India, from the citizenship lists. Poof. Gone. Four million. In one state. And, to no one’s surprise, the majority of the four million are women. Even if women weren’t overrepresented in the rollcall of the suddenly disappeared, the impact on women, individually and collectively, is particularly deep and vicious, and is particular to policy formation in patriarchal states and societies.
Today, the Indian government published the final draft of the National Register of Citizens, NRC, for Assam. Assam has been experiencing a considerable population growth over the last decade. About two-thirds of the state is Hindu, and one third is Muslim. For over seventy years, Indigenous Assamese, in particular the Bodo, and Bengali Muslims have opposed each other, often violently.
Those dropped from today’s citizenship lists are largely, almost exclusively, Bengali Muslims. Many view this as part of the national government’s saffron policies, turning secular multicultural India into Hindu India. Whatever the reasons, the NRC predictably targets, and eliminates, Bengali Muslim women. Shorbhanu Nessa’s story is typical of many Bengali Muslim women in Assam … and typical of many women across India and beyond.
Shorbhanu Nessa married before she was 18. She is surrounded by nevers that result in her elimination from the NRC: never went to school, never owned property, never had a bank account, never thought she needed to. She is the mother of five adult children. As far as Shorbhanu Nessa knew, being married to her husband was sufficient. Not any longer.
Shorbhanu Nessa’s son, Hussain Ahmad Madani, explains, “Because she never voted in her maiden home, she had no way to prove now that she was her father’s daughter. Her father’s legacy data is there, but she has no document to establish her linkage to him. There is no school certificate which would have mentioned his name. Her family settled in this char (a sand bar by a river in Assamese) when she was one-and-a-half years old after their char (Majarlega Char) was swallowed by the Brahmaputra. She was married off to my father in this same char. Though her father passed away, everyone in the neighbourhood knew whose daughter she was; trouble began when documentary evidence was sought by the NRC authorities to prove who her father was.”
Everyone knew, but this particular category of everyone doesn’t count.
Many of those who were dropped from the rolls are women. Almost all of them are Muslim. Most, if not all, are married. As of yet, there’s not an exact gender breakdown of the disappeared, but the stories are everywhere, repeating one another.
No matter how one cuts it, the design for the data collection for the NCR predictably attacked Muslim individuals and communities, who, for various reasons, would not have the documentary evidence to prove what everyone in the neighborhood knew and had known for years, decades and generations. What is it called when millions of people are stripped of their citizenship? Genocide.
But there’s something else here. The NRC structures specifically targeted Bengali Muslim women of Shorbhanu Nessa’s generation. In 1988, the voting age was lowered from 21 to 18. Bengali Muslim women, like Shorbhanu Nessa, were `encouraged’ to marry before they turned 18. Thus, they never voted using their birth, or maiden, names, and so now they can’t prove they are, and were, who they are, and were, precisely because they were dutiful daughters. None of this is surprising. It’s part of publicly and widely known culture in Assam, and it’s equally part of the NRC plan. The way the data was collected meant Bengali Muslim women would be disappeared, in large numbers, and that was perfectly fine with both Assamese officials and those in the national government. What’s it called when millions of women are disappeared in a single day? Femicide. In this world, citizenship is life. In one fell swoop, India created the single largest stateless population ever, and at the heart of that effort is the nation-State assault on women.
(Photo Credit: The Wire / Sangeeta Barooah Pisharoty)
This Women’s Day, Let Us Celebrate the Organic Change in the Way Protests Are Held https://thewire.in/women/womens-day-protests-celebrate-organic-change
‘How can I go back?’ Delhi’s fearful Muslims mourn riot dead https://www.theguardian.com/world/2020/mar/06/how-can-i-go-back-delhi-fearful-muslims-mourn-riot-dead
‘The Government Has Done This’: Inside India’s Muslim Pogrom via @thenation https://www.thenation.com/article/world/india-delhi-violence/
Bidar Court Says Play on CAA by School Students Was Not Seditious https://thewire.in/law/bidar-court-caa-play-sedition
Mumbai Bagh: Police Pull off Tarp Used to Shield Protesters From Sun in Dawn ‘Attack’ https://thewire.in/rights/mumbai-bagh-police-action
On Women’s Day, the Stories of Riot Victims Who Haven’t Lost Hope https://thewire.in/women/on-womens-day-the-stories-of-riot-victims-who-havent-lost-hope
How Men Turned a Peaceful, Women-Led Protest Into an Excuse to Riot https://thewire.in/women/men-women-protests-delhi-riot
How Rightwing Media Outlets’ Obsession with Shaheen Bagh Led to False Reporting https://thewire.in/media/rightwing-media-channels-shaheen-bagh
To Stop Deoband Women’s Protest, UP Police Target the Men in Their Families https://thewire.in/rights/deoband-anti-caa-protest-up-police
Delhi riots: ‘No-one who saw the photo thought I would survive’ https://www.bbc.com/news/av/world-asia-india-51837787/delhi-riots-no-one-who-saw-the-photo-thought-i-would-survive
As Amit Shah Praises Delhi Police, Riot Victims Tell a Different Story https://thewire.in/communalism/delhi-riots-amit-shah-muslims-delhi-police
‘De-Link NPR From Census’: 1,100 Women Write to CMs of Every State https://thewire.in/women/women-chief-ministers-npr-letter
‘We’ll Guard Against Coronavirus But Fear Detention Centres More Than Disease’ https://thewire.in/rights/shaheen-bagh-coronavirus
Over one thousand women write to Chief Ministers opposing NPR https://kafila.online/2020/03/20/over-one-thousand-women-write-to-chief-ministers-opposing-npr/
How India is on the verge of a massive refugee crisis of its own making https://www.opendemocracy.net/en/oureconomy/how-india-verge-massive-refugee-crisis-its-own-making/
‘Our Fight Is Still On’: Shaheen Bagh’s Spirit Remains Unbroken https://thewire.in/rights/shaheen-bagh-protest-police
Caught on camera: How a large police contingent cleared Delhi’s Shaheen Bagh sit-in protest https://scroll.in/video/957073/caught-on-camera-how-a-large-police-contingent-cleared-delhis-shaheen-bagh-sit-in-protest
After a 101-Day Sit-in, Shaheen Bagh Protest Cleared Due to Coronavirus Lockdown https://thewire.in/rights/shaheen-bagh-cleared-coronavirus-lockdown
Waiting for Citizenship
https://www.epw.in/journal/2020/13/commentary/waiting-citizenship.html
Not a Personal Win, It’s the Win of Anti-CAA Forces in Assam: Ajit Bhuyan on Bagging RS Seat https://thewire.in/politics/ajit-bhuyan-interview-rajya-sabha
60-year-old woman lodged in Assam detention camp dies, toll rises to 30 https://indianexpress.com/article/north-east-india/assam/woman-lodged-in-assam-detention-camp-dies-6351177/
60-Year-Old Woman Passes Away at Assam Detention Centre, 30th Death Since 2016 https://thewire.in/rights/assam-detention-centre-death
A Response to Hiren Gohain: The NRC is a Product of Xenophobia in Assam https://www.epw.in/engage/article/response-hiren-gohain-nrc-product-xenophobia-assam
Nizamuddin, the Newest Chapter in the Assamese Distrust of the ‘Miya’ https://thewire.in/communalism/nizamuddin-the-newest-chapter-in-the-assamese-distrust-of-the-miya
International Human Rights Group Urges Parliament to Repeal CAA https://thewire.in/rights/human-rights-watch-caa-india-modi
The government’s disingenuous defence of the CAA and NRC in the Supreme Court https://caravanmagazine.in/law/the-governments-disingenous-defence-of-caa-and-nrc-in-the-supreme-court
Citizenship Amendment Act: Exclusionary Nationhood Hiding Behind the Veneer of Liberal Citizenship https://www.epw.in/engage/article/research-radio-podcast-citizenship-amendment-act-anupama-roy
The CAA’s Provision for Cancelling OCI Registration Is Aimed at Punishing Dissenters https://thewire.in/rights/citizenship-amendment-act-oci-cardholder
1,100 Feminists Condemn Crackdown on Muslim Women Anti-CAA Activists https://thewire.in/communalism/muslim-women-anti-caa-activists-statements
Thousands of Protesters Take to Streets as Anti-CAA, Anti-EIA Agitations Erupt in Assam https://thewire.in/rights/thousands-of-protesters-take-to-streets-as-anti-caa-anti-eia-agitations-erupt-in-assam
Assam’s anti-CAA stir has birthed new parties. Can they be the promised political alternative? https://scroll.in/article/975194/assams-anti-caa-stir-has-birthed-new-parties-can-they-be-the-promised-political-alternative
10,000 Ineligible Names To Be Deleted From Final NRC In Assam https://thewire.in/rights/ineligible-names-to-be-deleted-final-nrc-assam
Is the final NRC published in Assam unravelling under political pressure? https://scroll.in/article/976739/is-the-final-nrc-published-in-assam-unravelling-under-political-pressure
CAA and dissent – the mere passing of a law does not imply democratic consensus: Abhik chimni https://kafila.online/2020/11/09/caa-and-dissent-the-mere-passing-of-a-law-does-not-imply-democratic-consensus-abhik-chimni/
Struggle Against Fascism: Some Reflections On Muslim Women’s Anti-CAA Protests https://feminisminindia.com/2020/11/13/fascism-caa-nrc-muslim-women-protests/
‘How many more days this way, democracy?’: Five poems of lamentation and love from Assam https://scroll.in/article/978539/how-many-more-days-this-way-democracy-five-poems-of-lamentation-and-love-from-assam
Why objecting to the Citizenship Amendment Act in India matters to us all https://www.dailymaverick.co.za/article/2020-11-23-why-objecting-to-the-citizenship-amendment-act-in-india-matters-to-us-all/
Anti-CAA protests vs farmers’ stir: BJP’s differing reactions betray its view of India’s Muslims https://scroll.in/article/980474/what-the-bjps-differing-reactions-to-anti-caa-and-farmers-protests-tell-us-about-how-it-sees-india
In the North East, the Citizenship Amendment Act has activated a fresh wave of nativist sentiment https://scroll.in/article/979452/in-the-north-east-the-citizenship-amendment-act-has-activated-a-fresh-wave-of-nativist-sentiment
Anti-CAA Protests Begin Again in Assam https://thewire.in/rights/anti-caa-protests-begin-again-in-assam
‘We were here’: What the anti-CAA protests meant to this law student https://scroll.in/article/980314/we-were-here-what-the-anti-caa-protests-meant-to-this-law-student
Oh Dan!
This is so sad and annoying at the same time. We hope the BJP government will correct this wrong. Thank you for bringing us this story and making the story of these mothers heard.
Thanks for reading and your reply. Given the past couple years, particularly CAA, we doubt the current government will do anything to `correct’ this.
One Year After Anti-CAA Stir: From Parivartan Chowk to Ghanta Ghar https://thewire.in/video/watch-anti-caa-protests-parivartan-chowk-ghanta-ghar-uttar-pradesh
From the CAA and NRC to Love Jihad: India’s Anti-Muslim Journey https://thewire.in/communalism/watch-from-the-caa-and-nrc-to-love-jihad-indias-anti-muslim-journey
The NRC in Assam doesn’t just violate human rights of millions – it also breaks international law https://scroll.in/article/983130/the-nrc-in-assam-doesnt-just-violate-human-rights-it-also-breaks-international-law